Since it became notorious 20 years ago with suspicions about links to the Oklahoma City bombing, this village seems frozen in time. True, some signs of modernization have crept in. The old, dimly lit chapel has been replaced with a 7,200-square-foot worship area, residents are now equipped with cellphones and Wi-Fi — although the service can sometimes be a little spotty — and the students at Bethel Christian School go on outings and compete in national contests. One thing about Elohim City, however, will probably never change. Residents are adherents of Christian Identity, which teaches that white Anglo-Saxons, not Jews, are God’s chosen people and that America, not Israel, is the promised land. According to Identity, Jews are descendants of Satan, and nonwhites are pre-Adamic, a lower form of species than whites. Over the years, suspicions have swirled. The community has been called “Love City,” “Hate City,” a nudist colony and a cult. Stories circulated that they had built an underground bunker and had acquired arsenals, tanks and rocket missiles. One man claimed that Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh was buried there after his execution. None of that is true, say John and David Millar, sons of the community’s late founder and patriarch, Robert Millar. “We don’t deny there’s been people who have come through and left who were up to no good,” David Millar said. “But nobody that’s a resident here would espouse any kind of terrorism.” No one in this village, the brothers say, had anything to do with the Oklahoma City bombing. “We were accused of possibly…...